To Teach Kindness: The Dilemma

This year, as you know, I decided to use dystopian literature as the vehicle to discuss making the world a kinder place. To use it as a backdrop upon which to show its opposite. We have read four novels while working on a long term project to counteract the Hate Map found on The Southern Poverty Law Center’s website. Our goal – to research groups working for social justice and peace, write articles about those groups, create an interactive map connected to the articles, and send it to The Southern Poverty Law Center to post beside the hate map.

The dilemma?  To do the work, I had to ask my students to review the hate map articles to determine the content and format of their “love group” articles. Repeatedly, I have found myself cringing as I tell them to look at the hate map site for help.

Many of them had never heard of these groups and were horrified. As we come to the end of this project, I do not know yet, if it opened their eyes to the numerous groups working against the evil found on the hate map, or if I simply reinforced their belief that this is an unkind world. I know that they believe this because I gave a kindness pre-assessment for my professional goals this year. Their responses saddened me. I celebrate kindness in my classroom every day, but it is only a few minutes at a time.

I plan on asking them to reflect on this project when it is complete to see if they see the world as more evil or less. I feel as if I am holding my breathe waiting on their responses.

Pain or pleasure?

 

1984 and Brave New World explore the idea of control (motivation), one through pain, one through pleasure. For the protagonists in both, Winston and the Savage are dead, metaphorically and literally, respectively.

As I stand before my students, I wonder if our system of education has not embraced the control of 1984, while the students have embraced the control of Brave New World. Educators say we are teaching, which infers learning. However, if the students only know the information the day of the test, did they learn? If they don’t, was the information valuable? Grades become a punishment rather than reward as students drown in the useless.  The students tell us that they drink on the weekends to escape the pain of the week of school – that it is the only time they can not feel stressed. That is their “soma”, grades are our Room 101.

Ultimately, the dilemma for me, as an educator, has become, does this year of dystopia improve their lives as I always hope education will?

Control in Dystopia and Now?

This idea of control through pain or pleasure will be exciting to examine as it relates to the reality of my students’ world. Which are we, 1984 or Brave New World or a combination of both? What is controlling my teaching? What is my ethical responsibility to my students as the literature we study is immediately relevant?

Dystopian Words – Educational or Destructive?

Great Courses offers a course on Utopian and Dystopian literature. It sound exciting, relevant, and intriguing. I decided to design a British Literature course around the dystopian novels across the literary movements. Beginning at the end, we read Lord of the Flies followed by 1984. Each day, I questioned my decision. These tales use to be cautionary; now they are real – too real.